Band of the Year

FINAL standings for 2017 bands of the year

2017 Band of the Year

Championship Section


Whitburn

 

1st Section

Bathgate Band

 

2nd Section

 

Arbroath Instrumental

 

3rd Section

Irvine & Dreghorn Band

4th Section

 

Newmains & District Band


The band of the year awards are designed to reflect the respective performances of bands in all Scottish contests and also in major national and international contests throughout the year. A separate award is made in each section for the band which accumulates the most band of the year points in all contests attended during the contesting year (1st January - 31st December). Band of the Year points are awarded on the following basis:-

Scottish Championships

Each band receives 2 points for taking part, an additional 2 points for each band they defeat and with a 2 point bonus for being the winning band. To demonstrate how this operates, a band winning a section of 10 bands in the Scottish Championships would receive 2 points for taking part, 18 points for having finished higher than 9 other bands and a 2 point bonus for winning the contest, being a total of 22 points. The band finishing in fifth place in the same contest would receive 2 points for taking part and 10 points for having finished higher than 5 other bands, being a total of 12 points.

Other Contests in Scotland

Fife Charities, Northern Counties, Carnegie, Land O' Burns, Borders Entertainment, and West Lothian Festival, Scottish Challenge Shield, Scottish Challenge Cup and Scottish Open.

Each band receives 1 point for taking part, 1 additional point for each Scottish band in their own section which they defeat and 1 bonus point for being the winning band in their section. Using this example, if 3 bands from the same section were to take part in one of these contests, the sectional winners would receive 1 point for taking part, 2 points for having finished higher than 2 other bands in the same section and 1 bonus point for winning the section, being a total of 4 points. In the same example, the band finishing second would receive 2 points and the band finishing third in the section would receive 1 point.

For the West Lothian Festival, points will only be awarded based on the ultimate result of the contest. Assuming all of the bands in the contest are Scottish and in the same section, the winners of the contest will therefore receive 7 points (1 for taking part, 5 for having finished higher than 5 other bands and 1 bonus point for winning the contest), the runners up in the final will receive 5 points, each band taking part will receive 3.5 points.

Major National and International Contests

(National Championship Finals - all sections, British Open, Grand Sheild, Senior Cup, Senior Trophy, European Championships, Scottish Open, International Masters, Brass in Concert, Mineworkers and Pontins).

Each band receives 1 point for taking part, 1 additional point for each Scottish band in their own section which they defeat, 1 bonus point for being the highest placed Scottish band in their section in the event and an additional bonus point if they were to be the overall winners of the event. Using the 2003 Scottish Open result as an example, Scottish Co-op receive 1 point for taking part, 6 points for defeating 6 other Scottish Championship section bands, 1 bonus point for being the highest placed Scottish Championship section band and 1 further bonus point for being the overall winners, being a total of 9 points.

In the event of a tie in the total number of points scored by two or more bands over the course of the year, the placings acheived in the Scottish Championships will determine the final Band of the Year placings for the bands concerned.

The tables for Band of the Year will be updated following each contest and the up to date position can be checked on this website.

 

Championship section

Whitburn 43
Co-operative Funeralcare 31
Dalmellington 23
Bon Accord Silver 21
Kingdom Brass 20
Bo'ness & Carriden 19
Kirkintilloch 16
Unison Kinneil 13
Kirkintilloch Kelvin 12
Tullis Russell Mills 10

 

1st Section

Bathgate 36
Newtongrange Silver 28
Johnstone Band 26
Lochgelly 25
Granite City Brass 25
Newmilns & Galston 21
Clackmannan District 16
Dunaskin Doon 15
Coalburn Silver 8
Annan Town (Magnox) 3

 

2nd Section

Arbroath Instrumental 26
Shotts St. Patrick's Brass 26
Broxburn & Livingston 23
Dalkeith & Monktonhall 23
Renfrew Burgh 21
St. Ronan's Silver 20
Campbeltown Brass 19
Jedforest Instrumental 14
Croy 10
Selkirk Silver 5
Perthshire Brass 4
City of Discovery 0

 

3rd Section

Irvine & Dreghorn 34
St. David's Brass 31
Brass Sounds Inverclyde 23
Buckhaven & Methil 20
MacTaggart Scott Loanhead 17
Langholm Town 15
Tullis Russell Concert Band 14
Dunfermline Town 10
Peebles Burgh 9
Whitburn Heartlands 6
Barrhead Burgh 6
Tayport Instrumental 0

 

4th Section

Newmains and District Band 47
Dysart Colliery 33
Penicuik Silver 30
Bon Accord Silver 'B' 29
Dundee Instrumental (St. Margaret's) 22
Kilmarnock Concert Brass 19
Newland Concert Brass 19
Dumfries Town 16
Highland Brass 10
Hawick Saxhorn 8
Stranraer Brass 8
Queensferry Community Brass 4
Forfar Instrumental 4
Creetown Silver 0
Callander Brass 0